Novels like Penitent (COMPLETE, Book 1 Stubbing July 1st)

All share GameLit and Reincarnation

Reborn Healer (b1 stubbed)
4.39
Also Drama
Blessed by Death: An Archmage's Second Life
4.58
Also Drama
Hell Hound Evolution
4.64
Also Drama
Max Level Vampire Rebuilds the Demon Kingdom
4.40
Also Drama
The Protagonist's Sister Is Actually The Strongest: An Action-Packed LitRPG Transmigration And Progression Fantasy
4.26
Also Drama
New Life as a Max Level Archmage
4.73
Also Drama
Eldanar’s Chosen
4.43
Also Drama
Dragon days: reincarnated as a dragon
4.63
Also Portal Fantasy / Isekai
Cultivation System: Elder Edition
4.62
Also Portal Fantasy / Isekai
Low-Fantasy Occultist Isekai
4.53
Also Portal Fantasy / Isekai
Hocus, Pocus, Hypothesis
4.48
Also Portal Fantasy / Isekai
The Lone Wanderer: A World-hopping LitRPG Adventure
4.48
Also Portal Fantasy / Isekai